This is what the cover of my copy looks like. Clean, but a little generic.
I think, when you get down to it, most of these long-term projects I try to throw myself into tend to come off the rails because I hit something that is a breaking point for me. I tried to do a Michael Moriarty Movie Marathon years ago, and it fell apart four movies in because I watched Hitler Meets Christ.
It isn’t always because I encounter something bad even. Just something that fills me with an ineffable desire not to go on. And obviously, living in a slow-motion action replay of the worst sins of the 1980s has not really helped fill me with desire to finish off the TV series. But what has actually broken me and made me stall out is something more inexplicable. So consider this my surrender: I am giving up on trying to be an absolute completist about this whole War of the Worlds thing, and I’m going to just move on and knock out the things that are actually left in my queue — one movie, I think three comic books, and seven TV episodes — and address anything else that pops up purely on the “if it tickles my fancy” basis.
I got through the Pendragon movie. I had no trouble with the two grammatically whimsical DG Leigh novellas. But for some reason, Stephen Baxter’s authorized sequel to the original novel has just brought me to a crashing halt.
Through some weird twist of irony, I first became aware of Stephen Baxter about twenty years ago, when I read The Time Ships, which is another sequel to a Wells novel. I liked it. I found it a pretty quick read, and I liked the way it fused a fidelity to Wells’s style with more plot-driven storytelling, and the way it confronted a lot of Wells’s conventions head on, such as having the Time Traveler learn a bit of Freud and realize that his visceral revulsion toward the Morlocks wasn’t purely rational, but might have had something to do with getting briefly locked in the root cellar as a small child.
One cool thing about The Time Ships that I learned years later is that Baxter had originally pitched it as a Doctor Who novel, but it was rejected. The basic plot of The Time Ships is that the Time Traveler, attempting to return to help the Eloi against the Morlocks, arrives in a completely different future, where a race of intelligent, nonviolent Morlocks have enclosed the sun in a Dyson sphere. The Time Traveler and his Morlock companion attempt to return to his native time, but only make it as far as a version of the 1940s where World War I never ended and London is covered by a concrete dome to protect from aerial bombardment. The changes in the timeline are suggested to be the result of the Traveler’s own story having inspired the H. G. Wells surrogate. The Traveler ends up going back millions of years, then forward to a version of 19th century Earth whose ecosystem has collapsed, where post-human creatures build the titular Time Ships, which they use to travel back to the Big Bang in order to find a universe with the optimal initial conditions before going back to his own “historical axis” to bootstrap his own story by giving his younger self the initial sample of the radioactive isotope used to build the time machine. Which, yeah, sounds like possibly a bit too weird even for Doctor Who… But… Weird esoteric beings seeding the moment of creation to force creation along the path they want is the plot of the eventual Doctor Who eighth Doctor novel Timeless, and that plot arc ends with the Doctor’s origin story being rewritten into a time loop in Sometime Never, plus, Baxter’s basic original idea of a first Doctor adventure based around history being repeatedly changed by the travelers’ presence shows up in Simon Guerrier’s The Time Travellers. Baxter himself would end up writing a Doctor Who novel in 2005, The Wheel of Ice. But this time, I don’t know. All the idea in here that I got to, I rather liked… But I found that no matter how long I spent reading it, I never seemed to make any forward headway. I’d look at the number of pages behind me and the number ahead, and I’d just be overcome with despair at the thought of going on for the length of time it would take me to finish the book.
How far did I make it? I made it to the end of chapter 14. Does that sound like a lot? Most of my reading these days has been to Dylan and Evie, so it sounds like a lot to me.
Chapter 14 is about the midpoint of Book I.
There are four books. I made it 70 pages, about a sixth of the way through the book. I stopped just after the Martians put in their first appearance. Seventy pages is kind of a long time to take to get to the actual warring of the worldsing. It’s not like I didn’t enjoy what I read, it just left me with no sense that the story was going to go anywhere in a timely manner.
Right from the get-go, Baxter makes cool and interesting choices in its characters. The narrator for our sequel is Julie Elphinstone, the ex-wife of the original narrator’s brother. That original narrator? He’s even got a name and for once, it’s not some play on Wells’s. Walter Jenkins gained world fame for his history of the war, but then went on to a certain amount of infamy for his unpopular persistence in reminding people that the Martians were still out there and might come back some day.
Reprising one of the things I enjoyed in The Time Ships, Walter’s therapist calls out a lot of issues from the original novel. Walter is suggested to be suffering from PTSD, which, given the circumstances of its discovery, they call by the adorable name “heat-stroke”. More than that, there are some hints that Walter might be on the spectrum, with his therapist, lacking modern terminology to describe it, suggests that the “heat-stroke” exacerbated an already-existing condition involving an unnatural detachment and difficulty connecting with other people. As an example, he cites the way he borrows his neighbor’s horse to help evacuate his own family without warning the neighbor about the imminent danger. Or that he never bothered to learn the name of the curate. It’s Nathaniel.
It is somewhere between true and false to say that my years-long War of the Worlds project is starting to wind down. True, there seems to be just about an infinite number of adaptations cropping up. Now more than ever since it’s finally fallen out of copyright in the UK. But I’ve only got a couple of episodes of the TV series left, and I’ve been dragging my heels on it for a lot of reasons, not all of which are, “Because it’s damn hard to come up with four thousand words a week about a failed ’80s adventure series.”
I’ve been mulling the question of what I’m going to tackle next for about a year or so. Heck, I’ve been conflicted about whether I’m going to have a “next big project” at all. It’s a lot of work. On the other hand, I think the discipline of actually forcing myself to produce something on a regular basis is good for me.
It would certainly be timely to start a new Knight Rider project about now, given its recent airing on Twitch. But I think I need to do something a little bit lighter. And one thing I’ve been considering was tackling a sitcom. I’ve been following a couple of fine folks on the internet who’ve been plumbing the depths of ’80s sitcoms, and I think I might be able to find something to say about that kind of thing.
So think of this as a test balloon. I don’t think this is a series I actually want to go all the way through (I mean, unless this post goes viral), but the recent passing of Charlotte Rae prompted me to look through my giant stack of DVDs I ought to get back to at some point and pull out one particular, ahem, “gem” from the days of my youth. Let’s have a look-see at the first episode of The Facts of Life…
It is August 24, 1979. I am just about two hundred days old. 1979 is a big year in other ways than just me being born. Somalia approves a new constitution. And later this week, the IRA will mount a pair of attacks, killing 18 British soldiers in the Warrenpoint ambush, and four others by bombing a fishing boat belonging to Lord Mountbatten of Burma. Next week, the space probe Pioneer 11 will visit Saturn.
Marvel wraps up the critically-acclaimed comic book Tomb of Dracula. Co-creator Marv Wolfman has crossed our path before, with his writing credit on Captain Power and the Soldiers of the Future. Apocalypse Now and Monty Python’s Life of Brian are newly out in theaters. Atari releases Lunar Lander, the first arcade version of a genre that had been banging around on minicomputers for about a decade. The first graphical RPG, Temple of Apshai, is released for the TRS-80 and Commodore PET.
Recently out on vinyl are Michael Jackson’s Off the Wall and Bette Middler’s soundtrack to The Rose, a film sort of loosely based on the life of Janis Joplin that will come out this November. The title track would become one of Middler’s highest-rated singles. She holds the third spot on the Billboard Hot 100 this week with “The Main Event” off of that album. Number one, however, goes to The Knack’s “My Sharona”, the first time a rock song has taken the top spot from the combination of disco and ballads that have dominated the charts for the past year. Also among top ten this week are the Charlie Daniels Band with “The Devil Went Down to Georgia”, ELO with “Don’t Bring Me Down” and Donna Summer’s “Bad Girls”.
1979 is a pretty interesting year for television, giving us all manner of important shows, like The Dukes of Hazzardand Benson and Buck Rogers in the 25th Century and Jason of Star Command and Read All About It and The Super-Globetrotters and Knots Landing, Trapper John, MD and Hello, Larry (Two fun facts: Charlotte Rae makes a guest appearance on Hello, Larry as Edna Garrett. Also, my parents went to a test screening of Hello, Larry. My dad recalled the experience fondly, prompting me and Leah to try doing a test screening, but we ended up seeing Undercover Boss and it was terrible), but we are literally on the very first day of the fall premiere season, so there’s nothing much to actually talk about right now in the world of TV, other than the thing we’re about to talk about. Doctor Who will return next week with Destiny of the Daleks, which introduces the second Romana and includes one of my favorite lines (“Oh look, rocks!”). There’s also a bunch of interesting future-TV stars who were born this year, which either makes me feel less old, or more of a failure since I’m the same age as Mindy Kahling and what have I done with my life? (On the other hand, I am clearly having a better time of it than Ricardo Medina, future Power Ranger, who is just a couple of days older than I am and currently in jail for killing his roommate) But again, mostly not in August (Though future aquatic person Jason Momoa was born on the first). Hart to Hart debuts tomorrow, but tonight, it’s just this.
Heres a weird and creepy fact: Todd Bridges is the only person in this shot who is still alive.
This is not, strictly speaking, the first episode; The Facts of Life was a backdoor pilot which aired as the first season finale of Diff’rent Strokes. This all seems like a kind of weird dream now, but the character of Edna Garrett originated not on the show she’s best known for, but instead on that show about the short black kid who gets adopted by the rich white guy. No, the first one. Yeah, this is a thing that happens in sitcom land from time to time. I will not bore you with the details of Diff’rent Strokes aside from pointing out that there’s an episode where the boss from WKRP in Cincinatti guest stars as a pedophile. Mrs. Garrett, housekeeper to the Drummond family, had been pressed into helping out daughter Kimberly’s exclusive upstate New York girls’ boarding school and ended the episode with an offer of a permanent position there. Which she declines in the Diff’rent Strokes episode.
The actual premiere episode proper for The Facts of Life finds Edna having accepted the position on a temporary basis. There’s been some retooling of the cast, the school has a different name, and Kimberly doesn’t seem to be a student any more. But we do get a guest appearance from the Drummond family, with Dana Plato, Conrad Bain, Gary Coleman and Todd Bridges appearing in a handful of scenes. And they knew where their bread was buttered: the Drummonds*[Technically, at this point in the series, Arnold and Willis were still using their mother’s name; they don’t change their last names to Drummond until season 7] appear during the cast role call in the opening credits. And each of them gets a full-screen credit; the actual cast has to share a split screen.
Notice that the smallest split-screens go to two of the only three characters who are going to stick around.
We find Mrs. Garrett helping the girls of Eastland prepare for a harvest festival. As the boys have never been to one (According to Willis, New Yorkers acknowledge the change of season by dressing the muggers more warmly), the Drummond patriarch has brought the family out to catch up with their seriously-she’s-never-coming-back housekeeper. Well, some of them, anyway. Arnold has hung back, fearful that he might encounter… girls. Yes, that will be Arnold’s running gag for his screen-time in this episode: he doesn’t like girls.
I, um. I guess that’s a thing. I’ve read about it. The whole “prepubescent boys think girls are gross,” thing. I only saw it in real life one time, and he turned out to be gay, so I’m not sure whether this is a legit thing in real life, or just a trope from fiction. In any case, it’s not really funny or anything. Actually, it’s kinda offensive. But it does give Arnold something to do in a story that otherwise doesn’t actually need him. The shame of it, I mean, other than the shame of the hackneyed cliche, is that it’s a good thematic fit for the main plot of the episode, but will anyone connect up these two parts of the plot? No they will not. Also, the main plot sucks and is even more problematic.
I’d better get that out of the way. I’ve mentioned it before: it’s my go-to example of how sitcoms of the early ’80s, even ones which were hailed as progressive in their time, have aged poorly and feature really disturbingly regressive politics. The main plot of this episode is that one of the girls insinuates that another one might be gay.
And I know you think you know which one, but you’re wrong; she’s not even in the show yet.
And this setup? It gets worse. It gets progressively worse over and over.
What even is this hair?
But anyway, if you know just a bit about The Facts of Life, you probably have a vague sense of the cast. Charlotte Rae as Mrs. Garrett, the wise matron, Kim Fields as Tootie, the sassy black girl; Nancy McKeon as Jo, the streetwise tomboy; Lisa Whelchel as Blair, the flirty rich girl, and Mindy Cohn as Natalie, the fat one. And, despite those being reductive stereotypes to the point of offense, it’s mass-market TV of the early ’80s, so you’re not exactly wrong. Except… You’re describing the cast from the second season onward (At least until season 8, when Charlotte Rae gets inexplicably written out). The first season is extraordinarily different. With the exception of Nancy McKeon, the best-known cast is all there, but only Blair and Mrs. Garrett are particularly well developed (Insert boob joke here). The first season is something of a clusterfuck of characters. In addition to the ones you’ve heard of, there’s also John Lawlor as Mr. Bradley, Eastland’s “hillariously” awkward headmaster, and Jenny O’Hara as his foil, Miss Mahoney, a teacher. She only lasts four episodes.
More importantly, there’s a whole bunch more students at this school than there will be in future seasons. Felice Schachter plays Nancy, about whom I have nothing to say because she’s only got one line in this episode. Julie Piekarski plays Sue Anne, who has more than one line but still not enough to really get a feel for the character. And, in a fact that may someday help you at bar trivia, a young Molly Ringwald plays Molly, who I think is maybe supposed to be the precocious one? Like, the main thing she does is correct Bradley from “girls” to “women”. You can probably see why they decided to prune back a bit.
The character who gets focus this week is Julie Anne Haddock’s Cindy, the tomboy. I have to credit the show a bit here: far too often, a character like this would be played by basically a supermodel wearing a baseball cap with her hair in a ponytail. Cindy does have her hair in a ponytail and wears a baseball cap. But she’s still a gangly tween girl with an athletic build and a strong jaw and even when they pretty her up for the “Holy shit she took her hair down and her glasses off and changed into something feminine and now she looks Hollywood pretty,” scene at the climax of the episode, she’s still gangly and awkward and we are spared any sort of creepy attempt to sex up a fourteen year old for the audience’s amusement.
So much Diff’rent Strokes-ology focuses on Gary Coleman that I think it is often overlooked what a wonderfully charismatic actor Todd Bridges is at this age.
We are quick, though, to establish her as unfeminine: on seeing Willis, she asks what he’s doing at a girls’ school, and he suggests that he might ask her the same thing. Arnold, on the other hand, is comforted by Cindy’s assurance that she doesn’t like kissing either, but instead likes sports (The two genders: kissing and sports). “You wouldn’t pull my leg, would you?” asks a nervous Arnold. “Why not? You could use a few inches.” So in case you were wondering, it takes three minutes and seventeen seconds to make a joke about Gary Coleman’s height.
Once the Drummonds depart, the fire marshall allows Bradley and Mahoney to enter so that he can fumble awkwardly a bit by accidentally insulting her.
“I’ll be depending heavily on Miss Mahoney to show me the ropes. She’s an old pro. I don’t mean she’s an old pro. I-I mean. She’s… been around. Oh, no. I don’t mean she’s been around. I mean, she’s been around the school for a long, long time. For not— not that long.” We also get a joke that I do find genuinely funny but also uncomfortable and I am also amazed they got away with it. Made uncomfortable by all this talk about her age, Miss Mahoney tries to suggest that she’s not that much older than the students, some of whom are, “About to burgeon into womanhood.” Natalie responds, “I thought all of us were burgeons.”
Miss Mahoney and Mr. Bradley have it out when Bradley decides to relax curfew for the evening’s dance. She’s scandalized by the affront to Eastland’s longstanding and immutable rules, and he responds by refusing to back down, repeatedly extending curfew almost to midnight. I guess this was meant to be their thing? And probably they were going to hook up at some point? I don’t know. It feels misplaced. The bit would work fine in something like Are You Being Served?, but “Normal human person not played by John Houseman is scandalized by headmaster changing the curfew at a boarding school for one night,” doesn’t feel at all legit in an American TV show. It’s not a good enough way to introduce the idea of her being stodgy about tradition.
Anyway, there’s a dance and a harvest festival and so of course there’s some sort of “Harvest Queen” dealie to be awarded. This is an inter-school event for some reason, and Blair, of course, has won it for the past two years, and fully expects to win again. Molly refuses to be judged by her cleavage, soliciting chuckles from the simulated studio audience as they mock her modest bust.
Molly Ringwald was eleven when this was made. Boob joke about an eleven-year-old, folks. That’s the sort of thing you can do in a sitcom in 1979, apparently.
Bradley assumes that’s the end of it, but Sue Ellen surprises the gang by nominating Cindy, which Molly thinks will stop the competition from being a, “Total flesh parade.” I guess the joke behind Molly is something like, “She talks like a feminist, but she is a prepubescent girl, and this is funny for some reason.” I guess that framed the right way, “Child is more woke than adults,” can be a solid comedy trope. But this feels less like that and more like, “Ha ha feminists are basically like stupid children pretending they’re grown-ups.”
So here, then, is where we get to what turns out to be the big central problem with the series as a whole. You’ve certainly heard me say this before. The Facts of Life is a generally well-made show which deals mostly compassionately and often realistically with the challenges and issues that are faced by young women finding their places in the world, which tries to validate a diversity of views and life paths…
And the central underlying joke, the core of the comedy in this comedy series, is, from the outset, and remains, for the duration of the series, “Isn’t it adorable that these girls think they’re people? Look at them wearing people clothes and pretending to do people jobs and have people opinions like what girls think and feel and do actually matters.”
Mrs. Garrett is delighted that Cindy entering the competition means they’ll have a “real race”, since I guess those other schools are all a bunch of dogs. Cindy protests that she doesn’t even own a dress. Natalie offers one she’d gotten from her sister (Natalie will subsequently be an only child), since, “I grew out of it before I grew into it.”
You may know that Twitch.tv recently concluded a streaming event showing much of the classic series of Doctor Who. Sadly, due to licensing issues, most of the stories featuring the Daleks couldn’t be shown.
Now, Twitch has moved on to running a marathon of Knight Rider, a show which is also very dear to my heart. Sadly, the same licensing issues are affecting that marathon as well, costing us some classics:
Wait a second; he’s got too many eyes.
But of course, we should all be used to this by now, given what we missed during the Mister Rogers’ Neighborhood marathon earlier this year…
I’ll admit, I cried a little when Fred suggested that they find a constructive use for their radical xenophobia.
And who could forget where it all started?
And if you make a mistake, you can just paint a happy little alien death machine over it.
This being the ’80s, this was probably filmed with three cameras, so the fact that there’s a cut between her throwing the water and it hitting him doesn’t necessarily mean they did multiple takes. But I choose to believe they spent a whole day throwing water at Michael Park.
Suzanne had a bad date.
While this is going on, Ironhorse and Harrison dress as hoboes and break into the alien facility via the sewers. “Are we insured for this?” Harrison asks. “Yeah, by Uncle Sam,” Ironhorse responds. Maybe the script editor was sick? I think I remember reading in one of these articles that they had a lot of trouble with the scripts, logistically. Despite the music telling us this scene is tense, their search goes off without a hitch. They stay out of view of the only aliens on duty, and no one’s watching the eggs themselves. Harrison decides to steal one for study. Ironhorse is not cool with this, wanting to leave basically the second they see the pods. This is yet another thing that feels like a throwback to earlier in the season: Ironhorse having a somewhat unjustified instinctual response to back away rather than confront when face-to-face with the aliens.
Are they dressed like hoboes because they’re undercover, or just because it’s cold out?
This was something we saw in the first few episodes, and at the time, I mused on the possibility that it was related to the “alien amnesia” angle. That Ironhorse, despite his bravery and professionalism, is just more affected than the others by whatever it is that makes people want to reject the reality of alien life. But, of course, that’s been pretty much ignored for like 17 episodes now, so is it coming back now intentionally, or just by coincidence, or because Jon Kubichan was working from nothing more than a couple of early-season scripts to get his sense of the characters?
Given all the indications that it is very cold out in Humboldt County tonight, its a good time he took the time to blowdry his hair between leaving the restaurant and showing up here.
What with his date ending early, Cash is able to follow Suzanne home and snap a picture of Ironhorse’s car as he and Harrison return from their raid. “Piece of cake,” he says, having trivially gotten the evidence he needs that… Um… That… A thing is happening at this government facility. A thing involving people entering it. I don’t know. I think the script has too much faith in us being impressed by them just saying Cash is a journalist. We see him do exactly two pieces of investigation in this entire episode, and one of them is “Takes a picture in the dark of a car entering a gated property.” At no point do they indicate Cash has learned a single thing other than what Quinn told him. Couldn’t we at least have gotten a montage of him bribing guards and looking through ledger books and scanning microfiche about, oh, I don’t know, all those military operations Ironhorse has been running across the country? This would be a perfect time to reference past episodes. Just dummy up a few newspaper pages with headlines about people disappearing and various things being locked down for counter-terrorism exercises.
One big happy family.
Instead, Cash McCullough, who will stop at nothing to get a story, does, near as I can tell, no legwork whatsoever. The next time we see him, he’s returned to the Korean Bathhouse to do a vaguely racist impression of the proprietor’s accent and meet with Quinn again to ask for help getting hard evidence. Quinn can’t get him inside the Cottage, but he agrees to give him a time and location for the Blackwood project’s next operation. He also claims that his reason for doing this is that he’s got a mistress in common with General Wilson. Once Cash is gone, Quinn pulls back the hood on his robe to laugh hammily at the camera.
It’s a good scene to go out on.
We have to bid John Colicos goodbye now. I hear they’d wanted to bring him back as the primary antagonist had there been a second season, but we won’t be seeing him again. His character is terrible and doesn’t make much sense, but come on. He doesn’t have to, does he? He’s John Colicos. He’s hammy and ridiculous and I love him. We are never going to get an explanation for why he’s doing all this, and really, what explanation could possibly help here? Is he trying to expose the aliens? Is he trying to shut down the Blackwood project? Is he trying to get Suzanne back together with her ex? Who can tell?
I want to point out two things. First, there are a surprising number of scenes of people eating in this episode. Second, there’s an Erlenmeyer flask in the background half-full of random green liquid that’s been left unattended over an open flame for possibly this entire episode. And it is relevant to the plot, but come on, a little basic lab safety here?
But before all that, Suzanne got a crack at studying the egg. She’s interrupted when Ironhorse demands to know how her date went. She explains about Cash’s investigation, with the possibly good news that the presumed leaker must not know the actual details of their mission. “That’s terrific,” Harrison says, and I’m going to blame the director for the fact that I can’t tell from Jared Martin’s delivery whether he means it or not. He’s exactly in the middle between exasperated facetiousness and being genuinely happy that Cash is so radically misinformed and thus their cover isn’t blown.
Suzanne barely has time to get angry at Ironhorse for bugging her table when Norton summons them over to see the supercomputer’s reconstruction of the inside of the egg. It does not look like anything in particular to me, but Suzanne quickly identifies it as an alien fetus. Harrison claims there were thousands of eggs in that icehouse, even though it seemed like no more than a couple of dozen at best to me.
While Harrison and Ironhorse are making plans to storm the place, Suzanne notices the egg move in response to alien transmissions Norton’s playing. I think. She says as much, but then Norton says, “Maybe it got too hot,” and the rest of the scene proceeds from that, with Suzanne working out that the eggs have to stay cold to avoid hatching prematurely. In what totally ought to have been the epigram over the title sequence instead of the Deep Throat thing, Suzanne tells Norton to summon the others because, “I could be midwife to a monster.”
Aw, hi there little fella.
The egg does hatch, and let me tell you, they do an admirable job on the alien baby. It’s this utterly uncanny fusion of the look for the adult aliens and… Cute baby animal. In the close-ups, I think they’re just using their regular alien animatronic, but there’s two longer shots where it’s a very tiny model with little spindly hands. The baby is premature and dying. Ironhorse wants to speed it along with a couple of bullets, but Suzanne stops him in the name of Science(!). A second later, she sticks her hands into the glove box to examine it, and it grabs her hard enough that she’s got bruises on her arms afterward. Ironhorse immolates it with a bunsen burner.
In the aftermath, Ironhorse is utterly deadpan and emotionless when he goes on to let everyone know that, “My plan is ready. We’ll attack tonight.” William Fruet directed four episodes of War of the Worlds, and the other three are pretty solid. Yet Harrison and Ironhorse both seem off this week, and Michael Parks is wildly inconsistent. It’s hard to blame anyone other than the director for this, but why is it only this episode that feels that way, when “Among the Philistines“, “To Heal the Leper” and “The Meek Shall Inherit” didn’t suffer from these problems.
Bad touch! Bad Touch!
The entire rest of the episode is an extended action sequence. I guess we should be used to that by now. I guess it hasn’t really occurred to me to bring this up. War of the Worlds has kinda fallen into a pattern. Since “The Meek Shall Inherit“, pretty much every episode has pushed its big action sequence all the way to the end and has usually run out the clock on it. More, I think, than they really ought to. Quite a few episodes, particularly in the last third of the series, haven’t had a proper coda. And it’s weakened some of them. My feeling is that there was a sense behind the scenes that the action scenes were their strength. And I won’t argue that. When I compare this to other military-style action-adventure, the action scenes do hold up pretty well. But by pushing it all the way to the end, they give up the chance to really resolve the narrative in any meaningful way.
For instance, the last we see of the Advocacy comes between Harrison and Ironhorse’s nighttime raid and the pod hatching in the Cottage, and it just consists of them ranting a bit about the humans having stolen one of their babies. They don’t even force the alien who dropped the ball on guard duty to commit ritual suicide. They just make the usual noises about how important this job is and how the troops on-site have to protect the eggs with their lives. They don’t send reinforcements or anything. I mean, given how important this whole “produce a viable next generation for our species” thing is, you’d think they’d send literally every alien they have.
But there’s, like, a dozen at most. If there is meant to be a large army off-screen, then the climactic battle suddenly comes off a lot worse, since, really, no, it’s a pitched fight between Ironhorse’s small, elite taskforce, and the aliens’ roughly similar numbers, but it’s not a massively imbalanced fight. (I am similarly hard-pressed to believe Harrison’s claim that there are thousands, or even hundreds of eggs; we see a few dozen at best and the layout and arrangement of them doesn’t indicate that there’s an order of magnitiude more offscreen somewhere.
The humans win. Ironhorse does lose a couple of men, and once again, we get some of Richard Chaves’s fantastic physical acting in the way he refuses to yield his professionalism with an outsize reaction, but he still makes it very clear that it hurts him to see his men sacrifice their lives. You can feel that he’s going to need to go have a talk with Bernard Behrens to talk about this tomorrow. But it’s a complete rout for the aliens.
That’s been happening a lot recently. Not every time, to be sure, but more often than not. I have feels about this. On the one hand, I am kinda bored with the tradition in this kind of show where basically, the heroes lose every single time up until the grand finale, or where the heroes are allowed “small” victories but never make any progress in the overall war. What we have here is actual, tangible escalation. Back at the beginning of the series, it felt like they were establishing a pattern: the team would uncover the alien plot, go in, kill some aliens, stop the plan, but it would turn out that the aliens had already accomplished enough of what they wanted that they made significant forward progress. “Thy Kingdom Come” ends with Harrison frustrated that they’re losing the war due to so many resurrected aliens escaping. The aliens evacuate their town in “A Multitude of Idols” before Ironhorse can bring in the cavalry. The aliens at Fort Streetor are defeated in “The Second Seal“, but the list of alien dump sites is lost. But when you get to the middle of the season, the team starts actually winning outright, not just stopping the immediate scheme of the week, but preventing the aliens from achieving their larger goals.
Quinn tells Cash that the Blackwood Project is a covert ops group tasked with the mass murder of illegal immigrants on American soil.
This week, we will have substantially less clickbaity Deep Throat references, but heres a picture of two half-naked dudes in a Korean Bathhouse anyway.
It’s moments like this that feed into why it’s taking me roughly ten times longer to write about this show than it took them to make it. It’s not like we haven’t seen this sort of thing before; the repeated times Ironhorse has called in military strikes on small midwestern universities or declared martial law over hospitals, and everyone just rolls with it? This show has repeatedly proceeded from the supposition that it is entirely reasonable and believable for the military to be engaged in combat operations on US soil apparently against US citizens, and even if they do have to cover it up, it’s still not enough of a big deal that anyone reacts to an army Colonel marching into a small-town morgue and demanding access to an active crime scene with anything other than mild frustration. This was emphatically not the way the world actually worked back then. But on some level, I think we sorta felt like it could be.
And yet…
It ought to completely derail the believably of the show that any reporter whose credentials extend beyond the check-out at the supermarket would fall for this. Because it ought to be too obviously false. I mean, cui bono? The penalty for getting caught is tremendous, and what’s the reward for doing it? The main benefit you get out of a hardline stance against immigration is that you get the votes of people who don’t like immigrants. Which means that anything you do to hurt immigrants has to be public. You can’t run for reelection on a platform of, “Immigrants are mysteriously disappearing and we swear we have nothing at all to do with it. Wink.”
If I’d stayed on the ball and this article had come out two years ago, we could go back to my plot exposition now. But we can’t. Because it’s 2018, and the United States of America rounds up the children of undocumented immigrants and asylum seekers and places them in concentration camps. And it turns out that the actual thing that is unbelievable in this story is that the government is trying to cover it up. The current administration has proposed using the army for immigration enforcement. If news broke tomorrow that the Trump administration was sending out the army to perform mass executions of undocumented immigrants, it would be a surprise, but can you honestly tell me you’d find it unbelievable? Within a week, Stephen Miller would be bragging that the whole “Final Solution” thing was his idea, Sarah Huckabee-Sanders would be calling journalists unprofessional for using the term “death-squad”, and Jefferson Beauregard Sessions would be citing 1 Samuel 15:2 to explain how genocide is sometimes okay.
The hook for Cash is that the Blackwood Project is under General Wilson, his ex-wife’s uncle. And Quinn reveals that Suzanne is involved, which reels Cash in rather than making the whole thing sound incredibly fishy given that he has, in fact, met Suzanne, and ought to know that she is:
Morally opposed to mass murder, to the point that she quit her previous job when she found out her research was being used to develop bioweapons.
A microbiologist. A quick perusal of ICE’s careers page shows openings for jackboots, thugs, fascists, and administrative assistants, but not currently any for microbiologists.
A civilian.
Instead, Cash falls for it, hook, line and sinker. Still not sure what Quinn expects to happen. Maybe Cash is able to ply his sources to follow the money and verify the existence of the project. Possibly he’s able to get access to some redacted reports which reveal things like Ironhorse taking over a hospital or driving tanks into Beeton. Is Quinn is banking on Cash being exactly tenacious enough to get that far, but not enough to find out what’s really going on? Or does he actually want Cash to find the truth and is providing a cover story because “The aliens which everyone knows exist because of the 1953 invasion are back,” somehow isn’t as believable as secret government death squads? (Spoiler: It’s probably that one).
Meanwhile, back at the, ir, cottage, Norton goes to see Harrison, because he’s wound up about alien transmissions. “Norton, it’s three AM. How come you’re always showing up at meal time?”
Oh Harrison, you delightful weirdo, never change. Especially not into a grizzled, gun-toting action hero.
What’s bothering Norton is that, while he still can’t decipher the alien language, he has enough experience now to gauge the tone of the transmissions. I like the way this acknowledges some growth for Norton: he’s getting better at understanding the aliens, even if he can’t understand their language. We already saw Norton being the one to recognize the alien transmissions becoming chaotic when the Advocate was sick back in “To Heal the Leper“, and how he’s gotten even better at interpreting the patterns in the messages.
The thing he’s interpreted at three in the morning today is that it sounds like baby talk.
Dammit, War of the Worlds. I give you a compliment, and you pull this shit? The aliens are trying to hatch their babies, so the alien transmissions are in baby-talk. Makes sense. Sure. Okay. To be clear, there’s no scene later where they indicate the aliens are, like, doing some kind of prenatal education thing where they transmit messages to the eggs to help with their development. The eggs aren’t even in place yet. No, the assumption here is that because the aliens have babies on the mind, their normal radio chatter is being conducted in baby talk.
It’s like they looked back at “To Heal the Leper” and thought, “Okay, so when the aliens are sick, their transmissions become chaotic and random, I guess because the transmissions are feverish?” instead of the much more straightforward, “The transmissions become chaotic because the aliens are confused without their leadership.”
Harrison has no wisdom for Norton, but slaps him away from his crudites. Harrison’s a vegetarian, you’ll recall, which is why all he ever eats are salads and platters of raw vegetables. It’s almost as though no one involved in dressing the set actually knew what vegetarian cuisine was like.
I assume we skip forward a few hours, because the next scene has Ironhorse delivering the mail to Suzanne, and she, quite bizarrely, makes a flirty joke based on substituting “male” for “mail” and saying, “I’ll take one.” Plus five points for foreshadowing, but minus a hundred for what they’re foreshadowing. In case it’s not obvious, this is going to be a plot about Suzanne seeing her ex-husband for the first time in years, and it’s an ’80s TV show, so yes, of course the thrust of the episode is going to be how Cash is a shitty human being, but damn if Suzanne doesn’t still have unresolved affection for him and damn if they’re not going to tease the possibility of eventual reconciliation between them because after all, they’ve got a kid together and the laws of TV morality means that you always have to give the deadbeat dad at least one on-screen try.
And to “justify” all of this, we lead off by reminding us that Suzanne is an adult human woman, and that many such people sometimes have needs and desires for which they might desire the companionship of a man, other than the three she spends ninety percent of her life with because of her job. And that’s fine. That’s great. Except that it’s not really all that great because it’s here entirely as an excuse for Suzanne’s judgment to be compromised when it comes to her shifty asshole ex-husband on account of she hasn’t been gettin’ it regular and is feeling all tingly in her nethers.
Suzanne’s mail includes a note from the main switchboard informing her that her ex-husband called. Ironhorse tries to seem all casual and just showing a friendly interest, but since he’s facing the camera, we can see that this is a cunning subterfuge, and he is in fact subtly trying to grill her for information, since Cash McCullough is, of course, a journalist, and journalists are enemies of the state, fake news, what about Crooked Hillary’s emails?
I like Ironhorse’s sweater. Military Sci-Fi needs more sweaters.
Because Ironhorse has approximately zero chill, when Suzanne muses to herself that she wonders what her deadbeat ex could possibly want to be calling her for the first time since the divorce, he immediately wheels around and asks what Cash wants in an accusatory tone. We’ve established pretty solid by now that this sort of thing is part of his job, so why does he need to be a dick about it? He literally could have just come down and said, “Your ex-husband called the switchboard. He’s a scumbag reporter, so I’m extra concerned about this. Let’s coordinate on this so that I can ensure the security of the project.” But instead he plays all coy and then suddenly wheels on her like a hardass for the fact that her scumbag ex called her unbidden.
Other than that bit of subterfuge, Ironhorse is entirely reasonable about the whole thing. He knows that Suzanne wouldn’t tell him anything about the project, and just needs a report from her afterward. What he’s really concerned about is Debi. Not sure why, given that it’s been nine episodes since we’ve seen her. Suzanne promises to “have a word with her,” which is good enough I guess? I mean, seriously, he goes to all the trouble of being a dick to Suzanne about her daughter possibly seeing her dad for the first time in two years and then he’s like, “Oh, yeah, just make sure you tell her not to say anything.” I’m not even clear whether Debi knows what they do at the Cottage. We saw her down in the lab once, but we’ve also heard her talk about alien life as something speculative.
When I think “Conflicted emotions about seeing ones ex for the first time in years, coupled with the burden of having to keep my daughter from blabbing about my work,” the facial expression I always go for is “nothing whatsoever” too.
Anyway, Ironhorse thanks Suzanne for her cooperation and we cut back to Suzanne to see her have absolutely no reaction whatsoever. Not even one of her bizarrely-timed smiles. Just nothing. And then we cut to an outdoor ice rink, because this show is just galloping forward through its plot, unlike me, with my constant asides and shameless digressions into more exciting subjects like the Trump administration’s miscarriages of justice or ’70s porn movies.
Debi sees her dad across the plaza, but has to ask for confirmation that it’s him, because that is how shitty a father Cash McCullough is. That talk Ironhorse wanted Suzanne to have with Debi? Addressed in its entirety by the line, “Do you remember what we talked about?”
This picture is mostly just here to remind you that Rachel Blanchard is in this show. Its surprisingly easy to forget.
Upon seeing her father for the first time in years, Debi’s first reaction is to want to go off and ice skate so he can watch her. This is a touching bit of realism, as Debi, who’s very young now and was even younger the last time she saw Cash, clearly is desperate to impress her father, out of an internalized, probably pre-conscious notion that she needs to win his affection. Nah. I’m just foolin’. The writers barely comprehend Debi on a level beyond that of a prop, and they’re getting her out of the way so that the “real” characters can talk. Cash portrays himself as wanting to reconcile, apologizing for his past and claiming that he’s grown weary of the way the life of the globetrotting journalist has left him bereft of interpersonal connections deeper than the random women he bangs. He apologizes for that too. As long as we have the actors on-screen, the writers reckon they should stick to shallow platitudes; the actual meat of their conversation is handled in the recap Suzanne gives Ironhorse back at the Cottage later.
Say goodbye to Debi, folks. This is her last appearance.
Cash claims to have been covering the Armenian earthquake when the human suffering prompted him to reevaluate his life and the fact that no one would know or care if he died. Pretty pat story, easy enough to believe, and one thing I want to note about it is that the Armenian earthquake of December, 1988 is a real thing. I mentioned it back when we crossed through December, 1988 a couple of years ago for “The Good Samaritan“. That’s a bit remarkable, because it’s a real event, contemporary to the making of the show that dates the setting of this episode within a pretty narrow window — it’s still winter for them (Though a perusal of historical data suggests that it was a very mild winter in the Bay area, and hardly the Toronto-esque conditions we see on the show). In the past, references to major events in the outside world have been both fictionalized and sensationalized: a nuclear summit a few months earlier, a reference to a catastrophe involving biological weapons, and what might have been some stock footage of the Bhopal Disaster passed off as current events.
Consider this a minute. One of the elements of worldbuilding, such as it is, in this series is a faint underlying notion that War of the Worlds is set in a slightly nastier version of 1988 than the one we inhabit. I can’t say whether this is a deliberate departure from the real 1988, or more of an embracing of certain cultural narratives that are strong even today — narratives about society being on the brink of collapse. But if it is deliberate, then isn’t it odd, in a world where nuclear accidents and bioweapon attacks and armies opening fire on their own people and special ops units taking over hospitals and tanks rolling into small towns and all the attendees of a lima bean festival suddenly disappearing and counterterrorism operations on college campuses, the thing that allegedly makes Cash McCullough do some soul-searching is an entirely natural disaster?
Heck, maybe that’s meant to be a clue that he’s not on the level. Not that we need the clue. There’s no ambiguity for the audience in this; we already know the real reason Cash is trying to reconcile with his family. Whatever the case, Cash’s magic is working on his ex-wife. She’s agreed to have dinner with him. “While my mind was saying no, my mouth was saying yes,” she explains. Look, I get that it is reasonable for exes to have some unresolved stuff between them and it’s complicated. But Jesus Christ do I not need to see this story any more ever, and Jesus Christ do I not need another, “Oh, the smart and strong and determined woman is completely powerless before the rougeish bad boy.” Plus, Suzanne was married to this guy. So this whole “He’s got a power over her” thing boils down to “We couldn’t be arsed to think of any reason why someone like Suzanne would pursue a relationship with this jackass at all, let alone one that progressed to the point of marriage,” so let’s just make it “He’s got this magic power over her.”
I really like Richard Chaves’s reactions in this sequence. Pity they’re not in focus.
I’m as angry as Ironhorse is. Sure, he shows some sympathy when Suzanne tells him how Cash has no living family other than them, and accepts that he didn’t ask Suzanne anything about her work, but the moment she leaves his office, he slams his fist on the desk and calls Stavrakos to set up surveillance on Suzanne’s date.
Dick.
Hey, remember when this show used to be about aliens and not Suzanne’s sex life? While I was busy complaining, the aliens took over a refrigerated warehouse and moved their eggs there. Now, they’re only seventy-two hours from hatching. Fortunately for humanity, even though Norton hasn’t been able to convince Harrison of his “baby talk” theory, he has been able to triangulate the source of the transmissions, so Harrison convinces Ironhorse to take some time off of spying on Suzanne’s dates to spy on refrigerated warehouses. In a lucky turn, the aliens have holed up in the industrial district in Eureka (or whatever city the Cottage is supposed to be near. As we’ve previously established, there’s contradictory evidence for that, but when Norton is locating things which are “nearby”, he inevitably pulls up a map showing Humboldt Bay).
I can not quite get this map to align exactly to real geography, but I think the location Norton eventually zeroes in on is currently the address of “Bikini Brews”, which seems to be a coffee shop staffed by women in swimwear.
Just a reminder here: the aliens are based in the Nevada desert. The closest place they could find to refrigerate their eggs was in northern California. Are there no refrigerated warehouses in Reno? Ironhorse himself points out what a big risk that is. Obviously, he doesn’t know where the aliens are and the aliens don’t know that they’ve moved in a few miles up the street from the enemy, but Ironhorse essentially hangs a lantern on the fact that there’s got to be refrigerated warehouses that aren’t in major metropolitan areas, no? For example, there appears to be one right off of I-80 in Storey County. I don’t know much about dairy logistics but I assume it’s a thing that exists and all.
This place looks familiar. I’ll have to go through the series again to figure out which building this has already been.
At this late stage in the series, we forgo the usual back-and-forth where Ironhorse has to be skeptical for a scene or two. In fact, it’s reversed: Harrison doesn’t see anything noteworthy at first glance, but Ironhorse’s trained eye notices the passive security. We see a binocular shot of the cameras on the roof, and Ironhorse mentions electronic locks and sensors. We are not shown these because it beggars the imagination to seriously believe that he’d be able to see those from this distance.
Yeah, maybe mention that first?
Then he mentions that the guards are all covered in radiation sores. Way to bury the lede. They make plans to have Omega Squad secure the perimeter on the DL and return for a look around. In the mean time, they return to the Cottage so that Harrison and Ironhorse can muse at each other about why the aliens would take such a big risk. The scene reminds me a little of the scenes in both “The Resurrection” and “The Walls at Jericho” of Harrison guiding Ironhorse to use his military expertise to guess at alien strategy. But like before, this just makes it all the stranger that neither of them draws a comparison to that time the aliens took over a liquid nitrogen factory. Harrison gets as far as theorizing that the aliens need to recreate the colder climate of Mortax, but he can’t come up with a reason. Come on, Harry. You already know that the aliens are susceptible to heat, and you know that there’s been times in the past where the aliens have taken big risks like this. Even if he can’t work out that it’s a delivery ward, the comparison to Jericho and to “To Heal the Leper” should at least get him as far as guessing at it being something healthcare-related.
Peak 80s.
They get interrupted when Suzanne stops in to tell them she’s off on her date with the ex. This leads, as it must I guess, to a scene where the two men and the incidental music are all left helpless for a few seconds because Suzanne did her hair and now looks ’80s hot. This is supposed to be cute, and it is not, first because I do not live in 1989, and second because it is literally the exact same scene they did the last time Suzanne had a date back in “The Good Samaritan“, and I do not even wish to dignify it with any more commentary.
We leave Harrison and Ironhorse to their failure at working out the alien plot and follow Suzanne on her date. As we’ve only got like three minutes for this scene, Cash cuts to the chase and asks if Suzanne would consider taking him back, on account of he’s lonely, she’s horny, and Debi is desperate for her father’s love. Suzanne, thankfully, rejects him on account of he’s an asshole. She accuses him of having a habit of disappearing when husbandry and fathering are needed, which gives Cash a perfect opening for a fantastically forced segue:
“Disappear? You mean like illegal aliens?” He assumes Suzanne is playing coy, but lays his cards on the table, accusing her, though he is stunned to imagine it, of working with a government project that lures undocumented immigrants out of hiding with false promises of amnesty, then shoots them. He alternates between suggesting Suzanne has been an unwitting pawn in all this and softly threatening her, since he plans to do “the same thing” as “they” did with ABSCAM.
This forced me to look up what ABSCAM was. And it makes no sense at all as a point of comparison here. ABSCAM was an FBI sting in the early ’80s that caught about a dozen public officials taking bribes. Is Cash supposed to be the FBI in this analogy? That might make sense if he were setting up some kind of “sting” with fake immigrants for them to try to shoot. But still, he’s a reporter investigating a secret death squad, not law enforcement investigating corruption. When ABSCAM became public, there was some controversy over the possibility that the FBI’s tactics bordered on entrapment, but all of the convictions were ultimately upheld. Does he just mean that “When it came out that a bunch of members of Congress were on the take, it was a big scandal”? Had you heard of ABSCAM? Far as I can tell, there’s no “intrepid reporter who broke the story and forced the powerful to their knees,” element to the ABSCAM story like there is in Watergate. It seems pretty clear that the point of comparison Cash wants here is to Iran-Contra, but it doesn’t work out because Reagan essentially got away with it and by the time this episode was written, most of the related trials either hadn’t started yet or were still ongoing. Was it just a last-minute, “Watergate is too on-the-nose, swap that out for some other scandal”? Or maybe an ’80s audience would be carrying a different understanding of ABSCAM than I’ve picked up from googling it thirty years later.
Cash promises to keep Suzanne and Debi out of it in exchange for her help. She tells him to go to hell, realizing that the only reason he’s come back into their lives is for his story. “You’re the kind of bastard who makes the case for divorce not enough,” she says. I can’t even fully parse that sentence. It only really makes sense to me if I assume that “The Case For Divorce” is the title of some seminal women’s studies essay. But the only one I’m familiar with is from 2009, so probably not. He cements his asshole status with an ominous warning that he always gets his story at any cost. She throws her drink in his face.
I hope his redemption arc involves him dying. The incidental music agrees with me, going full-on Lifetime Movie as Suzanne storms out, leaving Cash to glower after her with a total, “The climax of this show is going to be me trying to murder you,” expression.
I’ve got to stop Christmas from coming… But how?
Gee, I bet that won’t be totally undermined in the name of a last-minute heel-face-turn to make Cash a sympathetic character and thus leave open the possibility of eventual reconciliation with Suzanne…